Throughout the VirtualBox 2.4.x releases I did extensive testing with Mac OSX as host OS and several flavours of Linux as the guest OS.
Basically, I found it was not possible to play a CD on my Linux guest host with Mac OSX as the host OS.
I posted on VirtualBox forum and while one Leopard user has since claimed success, the response I got from a seasoned VBer wasthat no, it was not possible to play CDs on a Linux guest with OSX as host OS. (And of course CD ripping is completely out of the question since not even the CD's tracks can be seen in File Manager or Rythymbox player).
I just downloaded and updated VBox 3.0.4 and in short, nothing's changed since I made this post -
http://forums.virtualbox.org/viewtopic.php?f=8&t=16960&p=72128&hilit=whisperycat#p72128
Is this a rather underhanded way of putting people off Linux? This is terrible negative exposure for Linux, which is in many ways a far superior home OS than Windows. What user would evaluate any Linux distro, find it can't play or rip CDs, and thendecide to give it a try anyway? Is this Apple at work? Has anyone using WIndows as the host OS, been able to get CDs to play in a Linux guest?
I've un-installed VBox, I'll try again in a year ;-)
VirtualBox
Virtualization package for Windows and Linux.
Version: 3.0.12
Version 3.0.4 still won't play CDs for Linux guests on Mac OSX
Feedback Type: Review
Contributed by: whisperycat Saturday, August 08 2009 @ 06:47 AM PDT
Product Platform: MacOSX
Used Product For: Less than a month
Recommend Product: YES
Overall Rating:
Ease of Use:
Support:
Features:
Quality / Stability:
Price:
Comments
Another thought - DavidRavenMoon
You know, this is like saying I can't wash my hands while wearing rubber gloves!You are evaluating software that runs on a Mac. Then you compare Linux to Windoze? You are running a better OS than both of them! Just play the damn CDs in OS X.
If you want to run Linux or Windoze, get a cheap PC and install it. Or use Boot camp.
Apple wanting to make Linux look bad? Oh please. Are you 13? No, really, you have to be 13.
Wednesday, October 07 2009 @ 05:04 PM PDT
Version 3.0.4 still won't play CDs for Linux guests on Mac OSX - DavidRavenMoon
Why do you need to play CDs in Linux when you can play them in the host OS? Makes no sense. Just play them in OS X.Reply to This
Wednesday, October 07 2009 @ 07:32 AM PDT