I've read many positive reviews regarding Hear so I decided to purchase it taking advantage of their Competitive Upgrade.
After a couple of days of testing it, listening both through headphones and speakers, I have to say that for listening to music this is terrible.
So far every song I've heard has sounded worse with Hear. It sounds artificial and overly processed.
I used a Sony 5.1 sound system and a few high quality headphones (Grado, AKG), and listened to jazz, blues, classical, pop, metal, rock, etc.
I started listening to music back in the day of vinyl and tapes. I could hear the difference when CDs first appeared, and they were rather mediocre. A few years ago I had a variety of MP3 players in my Mac, and I could also hear differences between them.
These days we have iPods, MP3s, and the "loudness wars." With some equipment, we can also boost the volume by simply pressing a button. In my Sony it's called GROOVE. I never use it.
I often record and mix music, and I know that after a while I need to give my ears some rest to avoid ear fatigue. It's bad enough to listen to modern recordings given the loudness wars, but to also use Hear is just additional punishment.
I'm giving it 2 stars since it's still in version 1 and hopefully it will improve, and because it sounds good as an effect for playing computer games. Having control over the volume of individual applications is also a plus. There's a lot of room for improvement, starting with a basic resizable widow. Perhaps adding some sort of Analyzer and automatic preset selection. Even in the 80s or 90s I used equipment that analyzed the music before it was played, and adjusted the eq accordingly. Changing settings for each song is awkward.
For those of you who want to use it when LISTENING to music, definitely try before you buy.
Others who are more casual about the music listening experience may feel that the novelty is actually an improvement in sound. For me it was terrible.
Hear
Sound enhancement software, improves sound quality from headphones, internal or external speakers
Version: 1.0.3
Are people listening?
Feedback Type: Review
Contributed by: epc Wednesday, August 06 2008 @ 03:17 PM PDT
Product Platform: MacOSX
Used Product For: Less than a month
Recommend Product: NO
Overall Rating:
Ease of Use:
Features:
Quality / Stability:
Price:
Comments
Some notes - epc
Thanks for the comment.I'm sure that many people like it, and I have no doubt that I'm part of a minority. But in many cases listeners do not know better.
This is just one of the problems:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3Gmex_4hreQ
I think that Bob Ludwig mentioned it in an interview. Bob Katz and Bob Clearmountain and many other mixing and mastering engineers have strong opinions about the state of modern recording, but I'm digressing...
Eventually I'll create a few eq. presets, but here are 2 ideas:
Make the equalizer window resizable
Allow users to automagically associate some presets with certain songs, albums, applications, etc. This could be part of the preferences.
For example, if I'm playing a First Person Shooter, I would like Hear to automatically launch using a FPS preset. If I insert a DVD, Hear could automatically select my Cinema Paradiso preset, if I insert Dark Side of the Moon, Hear could select my Floyd preset, and so on.
iTunes already has that capability when it comes to associating different Eq. settings with specific songs. Hear could take this idea much further.
BTW, I do like Hear as an effect and it can be fun when playing a game, watching a movie, etc, In my case I just don't like it when listening to music.
Sunday, August 10 2008 @ 09:09 PM PDT
Some notes - Prosoft
Hi there--Your comments are appreciated.. The thing about Hear is that we've seen the majority of users be very excited about it, how it improves their listening experience,etc.. But yes, there are some that don't like the settings...
One thing to really note is that you need to play around with the settings for your particular set up, listening tastes, etc.. That is, switch from different presets, but also adjust the EQ, turns different settings on or off (if you like or dislike the effects, turn them off).. The presets are really just starting points.
Thanks for your post though, we do listen to them and appreciate the constructive feedback--
Gordon from JoeSoft
Reply to This
Thursday, August 07 2008 @ 09:30 AM PDT