This is a biased review. I have an axe to grind. I'm pissed off at what happened with SuperDuper (and its flaky support of Leopard). Truth be told, I would have left CCC in the dust had SuperDuper not dropped the ball on Leopard. But I had to come back, because SuperDuper just plain doesn't work right under Leopard.
Look at history? Remember OS X Panther? I was using CCC back then to clone my drives and loved it. Then something awful happened. Apple upgraded its OS to Tiger. And guess what? CCC dropped the ball. It didn't support Tiger, so I grudingly had to switch horses and go to SuperDuper. I thought to myself, "How stupid! CCC had me as a customer and now they lost me. If only they had been compatible with Tiger, I would have stayed with them."
Ain't it funny how history repeats itself? When Leopard came out, I was happy as a clam with SuperDuper, but guess what? They don't work with Leopard (yet). I couldn't believe it! In fact, I cloned some drives with SuperDuper (not knowing about its incompatibilities) and nearly lost all of my data. How easy would it have been to tell their users, "We don't work with Leopard yet?" But the app didn't tell me, so I kept on cloning.
Finally, I learned I had to switch horses again and go back to CCC. I'm glad they're "back" and hope they continue to make kick-ass software.
Look, I'm a paid and registered owner of both CCC and SuperDuper. They are both outstanding apps, but SuperDuper just plain dropped the ball (just like CCC did back in the Panther-->Tiger days).
I'm pissed off at SuperDuper. It would have saved a lot of us dedicated users a lot of grief if you coulda just told us that you didn't work with Leopard (through a Software Update sentence?).
Long live CCC. It's not just important for what I do every day. It's essential. Data is life.
Carbon Copy Cloner
Comprehensive bootable backup solution.
Version: 3.3
Wow. Take a Look at History. CCC Back On Top Again.
Feedback Type: Review
Contributed by: marmaladewanker Wednesday, December 26 2007 @ 09:32 AM PST
Product Platform: MacOSX
Used Product For: Over One Year
Recommend Product: YES
Overall Rating:
Ease of Use:
Support:
Features:
Quality / Stability:
Price:
Comments
Confirming data disaster using SuperDuper under Leopard - steve r.
I hear you... just going through a major data disaster myself after relying on a SuperDuper Leopard backup. Could you describe specifically what you mean by "nearly lost all my data" by using SuperDuper? Thanks.Sunday, January 06 2008 @ 11:30 AM PST
Confirming data disaster using SuperDuper under Leopard - marmaladewanker
Well, it was really a combination of errors on my part.First, I backed up my 10.4 system using SuperSuper. All went well. Then I upgraded to 10.5. I launched my SuperDuper application (again) to backup my new (updated) system and made sure I had the application check with the server for "Updates." There were none. SuperDuper said it was up to date.
So, I presumed SuperDuper was compatible with Leopard. I started copying over my old system on my external FireWire hard drive assuming everything was OK. I was wrong.
SuperDuper should have "failed-safe" and made sure to tell me that it wasn't compatible with Leopard.
I *assumed* that no message from the developer (upon the application connecting to their Web site) meant that SuperDuper was compatible with Leopard.
My backup was then hosed and I frantically contacted the developer. He told me not to use SuperDuper. That's when I searched the Web and found out about CCC's compatiblity with Leopard.
There are many other gory details, but that is the gist. Imagine how much grief *thousands* of users could have been saved, if SuperDuper had just made a phony build that was automatically triggered when it checked for updates. It would simply present a splash screen that said, "Since SuperDuper is not compatible with Leopard at this time, please utilize another backup strategy." It wouldn't be just good customer service, it might have also saved their business.
Tuesday, January 08 2008 @ 06:48 PM PST
Confirming data disaster using SuperDuper under Leopard - kenm22
When a new OS is released it should never be assumed that any utility is compatible whether it be CCC, SuperDuper or any other utility. Alway check first.Wednesday, January 23 2008 @ 12:00 AM PST
Version 2.3 works with tiger - lantzn
I was using version 2.3 with Tiger before upgrading to v3. I'm still using Tiger and have also tried SuperDuper. I prefer CCC and have used it for a very long time.Reply to This
Wednesday, December 26 2007 @ 10:54 PM PST