Existing users, log in.  New users, create a free account.  Lost password?

Mac OS X  |  Business / Productivity  |  Office Suites  |  NeoOffice  |  Better but still not quite the equal of Excel 10.1.6

NeoOffice

NeoOffice

Office suite based on OpenOffice.org.

Version:  3.0.1

   [ Views: 691 ]

Better but still not quite the equal of Excel 10.1.6

Feedback Type:  Review

Contributed by: brilor--2008 Wednesday, January 24 2007 @ 02:55 PM PST

Product Platform: MacOSX

Used Product For: Less than a month

Recommend Product: NO

Overall, a good product but it has some drawbacks. Note: I'm only evaluating the spreadsheet portion of the product and not the others.

First, it is slow (it runs native on my PowerMac G5 dual 2.3 GHz, 4GB Ram) and is noticeably sluggish compared to Excel (I ran the same spreasheet side-by-side in both apps). Resource consumption (as viewed in Activity Monitor) is approximately a 10x increase over Excel, so that might account for some of the sluggishness. Startup time is the worst. Using after it is started is acceptable but not zippy like Excel. Slower machines than mine (i.e. G3, G4) might be unacceptably slow.

Second, some convenience features found in Excel (which if you enter a lot of data matter), are missing. The cell type ahead feature in Excel provides a drop down list of all items that match what has been typed. There is no list in N.O. This slows down my data entry compared to Excel.

On the positive side the .ods files created by N.O. are up to 4 times smaller than an Excel file. This is probably due to the meta data saving by Excel.

Overall, a great feature set. Even though price is always a purchasing factor, it is a one-time saving. Performance issues linger on. Since I use Excel daily (and have for years), I'm not yet willing to sacrifice convenience.

Brian S.
  
Overall Rating:

Ease of Use:

Support:

Features:

Quality / Stability:

Price:

1 of 1 users found this helpful.

Rate this Review

Was this Review helpful? Yes | No

Comments

2 comments |

Better but still not quite the equal of Excel 10.1.6 - shaunmcdonald131

The file size reduction is due to the OpenDocument files being zipped. It nothing to do with meta data.

Reply to This

Monday, March 26 2007 @ 11:54 AM PDT


Better but still not quite the equal of Excel 10.1.6 - muon

Uh... this is a Java application. Of course it will be slower than Excel. Since Excel is not yet built for Intel, however, the difference in performance between it and NeoOffice is much less noticeable on Macintel.

Reply to This

Monday, March 26 2007 @ 02:03 PM PDT