Existing users, log in.  New users, create a free account.  Lost password?

Mac OS X  |  Design / Graphics  |  3D / Animation / Flash  |  Poser  |  Superb

Poser

Poser

3D character creation/animation software.

Version:  8.01.10434

   [ Views: 630 ]

Superb

Feedback Type:  Review

Contributed by: Martin Turner--2008 Saturday, August 26 2006 @ 01:31 PM PDT

Product Platform: MacOSX

Used Product For: Over One Year

Recommend Product: YES

Forget what others have said: Poser is superb. If you want the proof of this, just look around at the high-end 3d applications that are now including Poser connectivity, or are offering to sell Poser connectivity for -- well -- almost the price of Poser.

I've been using Poser since version 1, on a variety of machines, from OS 8 to Tiger. It's true that earlier versions were buggy (especially version 3, which ate my hard disk once) but I've never had any issues with Version 6, neither on my G4 Powerbook nor our G5 Quad.

Poser can produce fairly simple, basic cartoony type drawings if you want it to, or it can produce photorealistic massive resolution art if you have the time and patience to take it there. Check the gallery at www.renderosity.com for examples of some simply astounding work. There's also a massive amount of support, both commercial and free, in the form of other figures, clothing, props, lighting, expressions, scenery, animations and utilities.

It's true that you can create impossible poses with Poser. But, then, if you want to illustrate broken bones, abnormal skeleton, or, indeed, an alien life-form, you need to be able to do this. I've never yet discovered a genuine position that I could not create in Poser. But, if you did, you can actually edit the models including the Inverse Kinematics without leaving the Poser application.

Will Poser create art for you automatically? No. But, if it did, would it be art anyway? Are Poser renderings sufficient to use without any Photoshop adjustment? Probably not, but neither are images straight out of a high end digital camera. Does Poser offer an incredible level of power and control which takes you an enormous distance along the path to creating inspiring, gripping artwork? Yes it does. At least, it does for some people. No tool is right for everyone. Poser is a medium, just like airbrushing is a medium. Not everybody has to like it. But the proof of Poser is in the artwork that many have been able to produce.   
Overall Rating:

Ease of Use:

Support:

Features:

Quality / Stability:

Price:

1 of 2 users found this helpful.

Rate this Review

Was this Review helpful? Yes | No

Comments

2 comments |

Superb - ironhawk

Again, I'm certain really good work has beenmade with the product, however, it stands that more people have issues with the stability and quality of the UI than not, thus far.

My airbrush doesn't cease to operate when I open InDesign or Illustrator CS2.

And, for basic human poses, the anatomy ought to be correct.
If I want aliens and broken bones, I can make them myself.

I thought my criticism was fair and objective, but it seems to have drawn out the fanatics.

Reply to This

Sunday, October 08 2006 @ 04:26 PM PDT


Superb - Martin Turner--2008

My airbrush used to cease to operate after about five minutes of spraying, and had to be cleaned out. Changing inks (or, worse, gouache) was a nightmare.

But why are we talking about airbrushing, or do you mean your Wacom Airbrush tool? I can't comment on this, as we don't use one, but our Cintiq 21" worked fine with Poser 6 (we haven't put 7 on it yet).

I think it's a little premature to say that more users have a problem with the UI than not -- or do you mean people hwo review on VT (which isn't the same thing at all). Poser has been stable for me since version 4. Version 3 was a nightmare. Actually, it's a lot more stable than QuarkXpress.

Bottom line: we use Poser in a professional marketing, design and advertising setting. We haven't seen another tool that does what it does.

Reply to This

Tuesday, January 09 2007 @ 06:45 AM PST