Existing users, log in.  New users, create a free account.  Lost password?

Mac OS X  |  Audio / Video  |  Editors  |  LilyPond  |  Lilypond is fabulous

LilyPond

LilyPond

Automated music notation & engraving system.

Version:  2.12.2-1

   [ Views: 1473 ]

Lilypond is fabulous

Feedback Type:  Review

Contributed by: pianis Wednesday, May 10 2006 @ 08:00 PM PDT

Product Platform: MacOSX

Used Product For: Over One Year

Recommend Product: YES

Lilypond was started because programs such as Finale, Sibelius, or Overture by default produce a score layout that is well below publication quality. While the majority of musicians might be surprised to hear this, genuinely professional engravers know of the problems and they modify the score to meet their high standards. The occasional element clashes produced by Lilypond are very minor compared to the engraving problems produced by Finale or Sibelius.

I came across a score by Meridian Publishing, Inc. that quite clearly used the default output. Fine for casual use, unacceptable for publication.

Contrary to what zimbop says almost every aspect of Lilypond's output can be modified. Granted, figuring out how is not always very straightforward. But doing things such as adjusting spacing and moving elements to avoid clashes is usually fairly simple.

The high-quality output of Lilypond is due to the fact that they haven't spent any time developing a GUI, but rather focused on researching excellent engraving practices and developing Lilypond to reproduce them automatically. As a composer who takes pride in my scores, I have switched to Lilypond and do not intend to go back.

Lilypond is probably not for the person who likes to print up scores on the computer with a minimum of fuss. But Lilypond is for the composer or musician who is willing to spend a little more time in order to produce a beautiful score. And it really only takes a little more time once you become accustom to Lilypond's input. But it does have a reasonable learning curve.   
Overall Rating:

Ease of Use:

Support:

Features:

Quality / Stability:

Price:

10 of 10 users found this helpful.

Rate this Review

Was this Review helpful? Yes | No

Comments

2 comments |

Lilypond is fabulous - pianis

Correction: The poor score was produced by Meridian Integrated Media, not Meridian Publishing.

Reply to This

Tuesday, May 23 2006 @ 06:43 PM PDT


Lilypond is fabulous - badmuthahubbard

<i>Lilypond is probably not for the person who likes to print up scores on the computer with a minimum of fuss. But Lilypond is for the composer or musician who is willing to spend a little more time in order to produce a beautiful score.</i>

One thing I have learned from the comp teachers at my school is that time is money, and a competitive composer is often better off spending a few hundred dollars to save a few minutes of production time. I don't much care about professional engravers- I don't intend to be one- but I am interested in what other composers use, and in this regard Lilypond is the exception.
The teachers here also emphasize that correct notation isn't nearly as important as clear notation. I've run into lots of cases where a part is easier to read if it is spread out more, as the Lilypond people criticize Finale for.

Reply to This

Thursday, August 24 2006 @ 04:08 PM PDT