Existing users, log in.  New users, create a free account.  Lost password?

Mac OS X  |  Security / Privacy  |  Encryption / File Protection  |  PGP Desktop Email  |  This product is flawed

PGP Desktop Email

PGP Desktop Email

PGP security/encryption for IM, email, virtual disks.

Version:  9.10

   [ Views: 783 ]

This product is flawed

Feedback Type:  Review

Contributed by: Rawtext - Arts&Bits Thursday, June 30 2005 @ 11:37 PM PDT

Product Platform: MacOSX

Used Product For: 1-6 months

Recommend Product: NO

The ideas and specifications for PGP 9 sounded just great. But alas, this product sucks. As I have a growing demand for encrypted mailing, my idea was to set up a special email-account for encrypted communication and to have it handled by PGP automatically - meaning that any incoming mails would be decrypted and any outgoing mails would be encrypted automatically (as long as keys are known to PGP for the communications partners). This is exactly what PGP 9 promised - comfort on receiving encrypted mails and no danger to "forget" encrypting an outgoing message. But I never got this working. The product wants to control my entire mail-traffic and I was never able to focus it only on the pgp-email-account. It just won't do. So I thought, I might live up with this, give it control over all accounts and then define the rules for each accounts, so it would control those non-secret accounts but do nothing on them. And this didn't work at all too. Sometimes it would store my settings but not follow them, but in most of the cases the settings weren't even stored correctly. Again and again I found myself with messed up settings after going into the app, and if they weren't messed up, they just wouldn't work. What a frustration. My mailclient (Mailsmith) is not supported and even manually encoding/decoding in Mailsmith does not work any longer (as it did on PGP 8). For me, PGP9 is a complete and utter failure.
At least they were fair enough to provide beta-testing for free, so I encountered all the trouble before wasting money. I appreciate this and put it on the pro-side.   
Overall Rating:

Ease of Use:

Support:

Features:

Quality / Stability:

Price:

3 of 5 users found this helpful.

Rate this Review

Was this Review helpful? Yes | No

Comments

2 comments |

This product is flawed - Daniel Staal

You should take a look at GPG. Similar idea (it and PGP can encrypt/decrypt each others files), but less overpowering.

There are scripts avalible for Mailsmith.

Reply to This

Friday, July 01 2005 @ 06:20 AM PDT


This product is flawed - Don Saar

My experience is that it is not possible to import an external public key which is vital to fully utilize PGP. In fact after having looked up in PGP Corp. help area as to how to precisely accomplish this which simply amounts to a simple "drag and drop" into "keys area", I continually get " No PGP Data - Nothing was found to import in the items provided". But this is not the worst of it! When I emailed to PGP Corp all I got back was the very exact and same help instructions which I had previously explained to them that I had indeed read and followed their "drag and drop" instructions. It was as if they had not actually read my email. I then replied to them again that PGP 9.0.1 is buggy and still yet will not import foreign public keys. My Mac: G-5 dual-2.5gig MacOS X 10.3.9 and I am entirely familiar with earlier PGP v 6.5.8 for MIT's free classic version [ http://web.mit.edu/network/pgp.html ]. Don Saar drdonzi@crocker.com

Reply to This

Friday, July 01 2005 @ 01:51 PM PDT