Forty-Two DVD-VX Plus
DVD and video file conversion utility
Version: 3.3
Friends Don't Let Friends Do Command Lines
Feedback Type: Review
Contributed by: Bill Cerniuk Saturday, January 22 2005 @ 10:52 AM PST
Product Platform: MacOSX
Used Product For: Less than a month
Recommend Product: NO
My initial intent was to simply move a video out of wmv to QuickTime. In loading Fourty-Two DVD-VX Plus, I was dismayed by the number of pieces which were being assembled to do such a basic operation. While the developer has gone to great lengths to wrap a bunch of command line junk with a Mac GUI, the fact remains that the GUI is just a thin veneer and unfortunately the command line EXEs poke through. It is ironic but this is considered 'normal' in the typical UNIX world where to complete any task, a pile of command line tools are required. For the typical Mac user, 'dismay' is what occurs and they move on to a more professional solution. To make a good application, the code needs to be extracted from the command line utilities and put into an honest to goodness graphical application built in Cocoa or Carbon. One or 1 CODECs, 1 application, no 1970's throwback command line hacks. Short of this, there is no possibility of any elegance as the interface between GUI and command line tool is problematic at best. +*** for effort, -** for execution. For DVD processing to QuickTime, highly recommend "OpenShiiva" found here in VT. Also recommend using the QuickTime "operating system" to provide any of 80+ output formats including DVI and MPEG-4.
Overall Rating:
Ease of Use:
Features:
Quality / Stability:
Price:
Comments
What is the point? - Ilgaz
A guy, or couple of guys made hatred command line tools work, made them easy to install etc. I started to hate open source command line zealots here. Move to Mac Linux or something and stay away from VT.What is your point sir?
Friday, April 08 2005 @ 06:29 AM PDT
Friends Don't Let Friends Do Command Lines - bladehawke
What is painfully apparent here is that you have no concept of the operations involved.A) EXE's are a DOS/Windows convention, they do not and never have existed on the Mac or UNIX platforms.
B) There is nothing "simple" about decoding one audio/video format and reincoding it into another.
C) One cannot just "extract the code" from the command line utilities without violating the copyrights on those utilities
D) Just the operation you were suggesting that you wanted to perform would have required nearly a dozen CODECs to cover the possible variations in Quicktime and WMV formats.
E) Before flaming a developer who wrote a wrapper that makes the command line tools usable for the masses, one should understand the work he put into it, and consider that what you are asking for far exceeds what his $15 application is capable of. Please move on to $1000 software and leave the man in peace.
Reply to This
Friday, January 28 2005 @ 01:00 AM PST