Good: Delicious GUI, intuitive to use, modest but snappy features, convenient, fun.
Bad: a bit buggy (ex: must manually get info and remove pasted icon if attempting to "paste over" an existing customized icon), and too expensive for all but the most hardcore icon fanatics. I have registered CandyBar and would be inclined to buy this too if it were discounted for CandyBar owners. You'd think it would AT LEAST be priced in line with it's competition. Iconfactory rocks, Panic rocks, but this app really isn't THAT much better than IconBox. It's very surprising the authors would choose to charge a more than 30% premium above the cost of an almost identical app by another reputable company (XIcons rocks and ChickenByte can hum a tune). And if your icons are already nicely organized in finder windows then the FREEWARE app Asticones has much of the functionality of both of these apps. Still, aside from the price and a few bugs (which is to be expected in a 1.0 release) this is a GREAT piece of software that I wish this student's budget could accommodate. I'm keeping my fingers crossed for a CandyBar buyer/owner sale price. Pretty please?