I've been using this for some time, after noticing that my teenaged daughters were spending an inordinate amount of time online. It generally works as advertised, and has a clean, usable interface. Well designed and professional solution overall, especially considering the low cost.
However, I found a couple of things frustrating. Some of these are beyond the power of the developer to fix, but they do hinder its usefulness.
First, the warning messages do not work if the program operates in the background. My daughters quickly figured out that they could run iTunes as a background app and never worry about the time restrictions.
Second, one of my daughters quickly learned that once her times expired she could just log in as her sister, which led to a couple of battles until passwords were changed.
Third, be careful how you set up programs, because if you set up an individual app you can't convert it to a group later (same with simple vs. complex time charting).
Fourth, the time graphs appear to be completely bogus. After one of my daughters used her entire 8-hour allotment of web browser time, a check of her log file showed 20 minutes had been used. Very odd.
Fifth, the warning messages do not always display.
Sixth and most problematic, when the warning messages come up after your time has been exceeded (say if a program was in the background), you have no opportunity to save the data. I would like to see a preference option to automatically save before quitting any program.
But these are minor issues. Overall, I find this immensely useful. It has helped me stay out of my kids' hair, allowing the application to deal with their use of computer time.
Mac Minder
parent & teacher tool to track & limit program usage
Version: 2.5.7
Great product, minor issues
Feedback Type: Review
Contributed by: George Pytlik Tuesday, July 08 2003 @ 12:59 PM PDT
Product Platform: MacOSX
Used Product For: Six Months
Recommend Product: YES
Overall Rating:
Ease of Use:
Support:
Features:
Quality / Stability:
Price:
Comments
Great product, minor issues - pohld
I don't think using software like this to limit kids' time on the computer is a cop-out. It's just a tool for doing the job. So rather than having to have the kids tell you when the're going to start their session and then you get out your stopwatch and then yell at them when time's up, you have this program take care of that. Think of it as a super-powered stopwatch. I see this as a tool that enables responsible parenting.If it works, that is. I haven't tried it yet. But the concept is great.
Thursday, February 23 2006 @ 08:23 AM PST
Great product, minor issues - George Pytlik
I don't want to extend discussions here into areas beyond the software itself. But in this case the software and parenting are so closely related that it's fair to respond.Those who say that it's silly to use software to restrict a child's computer time because that only causes them to seek a way around the restriction are contradicting themselves.
Whether you issue a verbal restriction or use software, you still have a restriction. Some kind of restriction is necessary. Children don't understand that they can be damaged by excessive use of anything, including television or computer time.
Parents have a choice of creating sometimes unpleasant arguments by watching the clock and telling their kids when the "time is up" limit is reached, or they can back off and install software to stay out of their hair. Both achieve the same goals. I've applied both.
In my experience this software is a superior solution. It is more consistent than having a parent watch the clock, and it removes the common childhood view of the parent as a draconian entity trying daily to limit their freedom. The child's annoyance is now directed towards the software itself rather than the parent, allowing the parental relationship to be free from arguments on how long they've been on the computer, who has used it the most, etc. MacMinder has been very effective.
Monday, May 08 2006 @ 03:17 PM PDT
Great product, minor issues - fishwhale
using software in place of parenting isn't really good. I realize this sounds like a negative comment, but it isn't. Any restriction placed on someone will lead to that someone wishing to break through it, as you pointed out. Man, this sounds like hell. Instead of common sense, a tool is used. ouch.Reply to This
Saturday, September 27 2003 @ 08:08 PM PDT