Punch! Home Design Studio - 11.0.3home & interior design app |
|
||||||||||||||||
|
|||||||||||||||||
Feedback Summary:
| Version 11.0.3: | |||||
| Overall Rating: | Features: | Support: | |||
| Ease of Use: | Quality / Stability: | Price: | |||
Key to Types of Feedback:
Reviews
Troubleshooting
Usage Tips
Developer Notes
Commentary
Featured Reviews
Won't upgrade in Leopard 



- Version: 11.0.3, 12/2/2007 01:49AM PST
(4 of 4 users found this comment useful)
Rogue
Went with Live Interior 3D instead 



- Version: 11.0.1, 7/30/2007 11:41AM PST
(11 of 12 users found this comment useful)
jdavidsn
We bought Punch and used it for a while. We ended up redoing my project in Live Interior 3D because the renderings were so much better and way better looking. With Punch, the 3D renderings are cruder looking. The lighted, shaded views take 5-10 seconds to render, versus maybe 1-3 seconds in Live Interior.
Punch is a port of a long-running suite of Windows apps. Thus it has more features than Live Interior 3D, including dealing with multi-floor layouts, staircases and more. It's also comparatively pricier (though still a tiny cost relative to a remodeling project.) The underlying engine seems like it needs to be modernized for speed, for super fast 3D rendering, and for sharper 2D graphics. (The blueprint views are so jaggy they look like DOS graphics!)
For simple one room projects I would go with Live Interior. For complex multi-room and multi-level projects Punch may be more appropriate, but you trade off the gorgeous renderings.
Punch is a port of a long-running suite of Windows apps. Thus it has more features than Live Interior 3D, including dealing with multi-floor layouts, staircases and more. It's also comparatively pricier (though still a tiny cost relative to a remodeling project.) The underlying engine seems like it needs to be modernized for speed, for super fast 3D rendering, and for sharper 2D graphics. (The blueprint views are so jaggy they look like DOS graphics!)
For simple one room projects I would go with Live Interior. For complex multi-room and multi-level projects Punch may be more appropriate, but you trade off the gorgeous renderings.
I am now looking around for a replacement.