Liquid Ledger Personal Finance - 2.3.3Complete money management solution for everyone. |
|
||||||||||||||||
|
|||||||||||||||||
Feedback Summary:
| This Version: | |||||
| Overall Rating: | Not rated (0.0) | Features: | Not rated (0.0) | Support: | Not rated (0.0) |
| Ease of Use: | Not rated (0.0) | Quality / Stability: | Not rated (0.0) | Price: | Not rated (0.0) |
Key to Types of Feedback:
Reviews
Troubleshooting
Usage Tips
Developer Notes
Commentary
Featured Reviews
Worst Car Wreck in Mac OS Software History 



- Version: 2.0, 10/19/2007 02:50PM PST
(0 of 1 users found this comment useful)
gryphonent
Here's the deal... - Version: 2.0, 10/9/2007 10:05PM PST
(2 of 3 users found this comment useful)
robbyx--2008It's pretty obvious from the enthusiasm that Quicken alternatives receive online that people REALLY want something better than Quicken. Unfortunately, few apps begin to measure up in terms of overall reliability and feature set. Yes, there are Quicken horror stories, but there are many, many success stories too. We forget that sometimes. My biggest gripe with Quicken is its dinosaur UI. When I see programs like Liquid Ledger, Cha-Ching, or iBank, I get a glimpse of how nice a well-designed finance app might be. And then I try it. And it's buggy. Too buggy to trust. So I stick with Quicken, as I imagine most of us do.
Most Recent Replies: View All 1 Replies
- Here's the deal...
Seems promising, but currently unpolished and expensive 



- Version: 1.5.6, 7/29/2007 02:51PM PST
(1 of 1 users found this comment useful)
Rinzwind42Liquid Ledger doesn't have many features, but it does what I need it to do: import my bank statements and let me tag them with income/expense accounts, so I know where my money goes. I've been using the trial for a few days now, my review:
Pros:
- Easy to use interface for importing CSV files, much nicer than what I've found in iBank version 2.3.1
- Defines several fields for keeping information about each transaction (name, memo, explanation, ...) that I've found helpful. I'm only missing a "personal notes" field (all the other fields I import from my bank statements, and prefer not to change)
- Double accounting model is very flexible
Cons:
- Gives some odd internal error when I try to import OFX files from my bank
- Looks&feels very unpolished, just some problems I've already encountered in a few days of use:
- There are four types of accounts (assets, liabilities, income and expense accounts) and the accounts list has four categories for these. You can actually delete these categories, but then they are lost because you cannot create your own categories, nor does creating say a new "liabilities" account re-create the liabilities category if you deleted it.
- In the accounts list you have to click the "balance" field to open the transactions list for that account, accidentally clicking the "currency" or "name" field allows you to change those fields. Now how many times do you want to do the latter? It would be better if clicking any part of an account would open the transactions list, and editing name and currency is done through an inspector.
- I've had a few occassions where I had the transaction list for an account open, and in the mean time created some more accounts, where the autocomplete would then not allow me to type the name of an account to transfer to (for example, I had an expense account "Books" and one "Bank Charges", trying to type "Bank Charges" always came out as "Books"!!).
- In the transaction list window, one can open an account drawer to quickly switch to the transaction list of another account. In the list, when an expense account is selected, there are columns "Deposit" and "Withdraw" which change to "Expense" and "Income" when an expense account is selected. Switching back to the asset account does not always change back the names of these columns, which means "deposits" suddenly look like "expenses"!
- Exporting the transactions of one account to CSV does not export the "transfer track" field if a transaction has been tracked to multiple accounts.
- Considering how much it does and how well it is designed, it is ridiculously expensive
All in all, this application shows promise, but I'd rather wait for the next major version release or a serious lowering in price before purchasing it.
Love it 



- Version: 1.5.5, 4/23/2007 02:13PM PST
S M P
- import QIF etc
- handles multiple currencies with ease
- powerful but fairly intuitive
- reports and statements
The UI is not perfect, but I've had prompt responses to my questions on their support forum, and it doesn't screw up any math!
Bought then Abandoned 



- Version: 1.5.5, 2/9/2007 08:27AM PST
vottamusic
To help prove that I am an actual customer, my initials are DR and my registration number for LL begins with "G0" and ends with "Q5". The Liquid Ledger people can figure out who I am, which will hopefully prevent them from posting a message saying I'm not an actual customer.
I did not even bother attempting to request a refund, because I would have become even more angry if they said 'sorry, no refund'. What a waste of time and money. I can't believe Apple actually sells this program in their stores.
Limit Functionality and Expensive 



- Version: 1.5.5, 1/9/2007 09:40AM PST
(3 of 3 users found this comment useful)
robbyx--2008LiquidLedger's interface is decent, but doesn't really offer much over Quicken. I like the fact that splits are shown at the bottom of the window, in their own dedicated area, versus Quicken's inline splits. I've always hated the way Quicken makes the user open and close splits in the register. LiquidLedger also seems to have pretty decent support for multiples currencies, although I never really tested this feature.
If all you want out of an accounting package is a ledger/register, this will do, but why not just buy Quicken? LiquidLedger is so feature poor in all other areas, from investing to reporting to online banking, that I can't see any advantage to using this program - especially since it costs *more* than Quicken. Furthermore, if you need to export QIF files, LiquidLedger's QIFs are problematic. I was unable to import them into Quicken, so I've had to manually re-enter all of my data.
As much as many of us are hoping for a "Quicken Killer" to emerge, there's nothing close out there now. I'm most optimistic about a new little app called Cha-Ching. The interface is a knock-out; simply gorgeous. If they manage to deliver a solid feature-set, stability, and good interoperability, they'll get my vote. But, for now, I'm sticking with Quicken.
Not impressed. 



- Version: 1.5.3, 12/20/2006 08:25PM PST
(2 of 2 users found this comment useful)
iGreg
After a long search....it's working.... 



- Version: 1.5.1, 3/17/2006 09:16AM PST
(1 of 1 users found this comment useful)
chan_lor
If you've recently purchased Mac OS X Panther, or plan to upgrade to the groundbreaking new operating system release from Apple, you'll want to get a copy of Liquid Ledger™ 1.2.1 for Mac OS X. This timely update to Liquid Ledger fixes a previous incompatibility between Liquid Ledger 1.2 and Mac OS X Panther, and a free updater utility is now available from <http://www.liquidledger.com/support/>.
Also in the works is Liquid Ledger 2, a major upgrade to the most refreshing personal finance solution available for Mac OS X. Liquid Ledger 2 introduces a host of new features and improvements, like scheduled transactions, customisable reports, investment tracking tools, and an unprecedented level of usability for this category of software. To show our appreciation for the continued support of our customers, Liquid Ledger 2 will be a free upgrade for all Liquid Ledger users. The first peeks at Liquid Ledger 2 will come later this year or in early 2004.
Pricing and Availability
Liquid Ledger 1.2.1 for Mac OS X Panther is available today and can be purchased online for US$45 from <http://www.liquidledger.com/>. Existing customers can download a free updater utility, available from <http://www.liquidledger.com/support/>, that updates any previous installation of Liquid Ledger to the latest release. Liquid Ledger comes with a 30-day money-back satisfaction guarantee.
************************************************************************
You received this e-mail because you subscribed to Modeless Software, Inc.'s
Liquid Ledger News announcement list. To remove yourself from this list, send
a blank e-mail to <mailto:liquidledger_news-unsubscribe@liquidledger.com>.
************************************************************************
The above is a statement from the author in 2003 that has never been retracted.
I have done extensive beta testing with the author since 2003 working on issues with LL 1.x.